- Dallas-Fort Worth Theater Critics Forum: 2017 Awards | Full List
- OUTSTANDING DIRECTION, Christie Vela – Straight White Men
- OUTSTANDING NEW PLAY OR MUSICAL, The Necessities by Blake Hackler
- OUTSTANDING PERFORMANCE BY AN ACTOR, Thomas Ward – Straight White Men
- OUTSTANDING PERFORMANCE BY AN ACTRESS
Jenny Ledel – Grounded
Christie Vela – The Necessities - OUTSTANDING DESIGN OR CREATIVE CONTRIBUTION
Brian McDonald – set and sound design, Grounded
Aaron Johansen – lighting design, Grounded
- Dallas Observer: Best of Dallas 2015 | More Information
- Best Actor, Alex Organ
- Best Actress, Jenny Ledel
- D Magazine: Best of Big D 2014 | More Information
- Best Theater
- Dallas-Fort Worth Theater Critics Forum: 2014 Awards | Full List
- Best Actor, Drew Wall, Nocturne
- Best New Play or Musical, Booth by Steven Walters
- Dallas Observer: Best of Dallas 2014 | More Information
- Best Stage Actor, Drew Wall
- Dallas Observer: Best of Dallas 2009 | More information
- Best Young Actor, Drew Wall
- Dallas Voice: ‘Exit Stage Right’ (Top 10 of 2008) | Full List
- “7. There’s a good reason Edmond (Second Thought Theatre) is performed without an intermission: David Mamet’s play is so abusive, so discomfiting to watch, it has to be experienced once, quickly – like ripping off a Band-Aid. This production, fluidly directed by Rene Moreno and brilliantly acted (especially by Regan Adair in the title role), zeroed in on the dark soul of a man unflinchingly.”
- The Dallas Morning News: TOP 10 OF 2008 | Full List
- “10. Best Dallas Premiere of a Show That Fort Worth Saw Long Ago: Second Thought Theatre’s Lobby Hero had strong performances in a tricky piece, but the same company’s Collected Stories featured the city’s best actresses of their generations, Pam Dougherty and Allison Tolman, in peak form.”
- Dallas-Fort Worth Theater Critics Forum’s 2007-08 Awards | Full List
- NEW PLAY OR MUSICAL: Snake Eyes at the Mardi Gras Motel by Steven Walters
- PERFORMANCE BY AN ACTOR: Regan Adair, Edmond
- PERFORMANCE BY AN ACTRESS: Maxey Whitehead, Snake Eyes at the Mardi Gras Motel
- EdgeDallas.com: Best in Dallas Theater 2008 | Full List
- Edmond by David Mamet
- Dallas Observer, Best of Dallas 2005
- Best New Theater Company
- Best Local Actress – Allison Tolman
- Best Local Actor and Playwright – Steven Walters